We're in the process of finding a new pastor...
He would definitely get my vote.
I don't think he would preach either of the subjects you suggest. (if you don't mind me varying from your choices)
I think he would preach on how we are all missing the whole point and he would straighten us out on what this Christianity thing was supposed to be about.
Also... I don't think he would "preach" the way preachers preach today.
I think he would sit on the edge of the platform and talk to us.
And it won't do any good to ask me what he would tell us because I am one of the "we" and I wish Jesus would sit me down and let me know exactly what is supposed to be important and what is not.
I would LOVE to be straightened out. I would LOVE to have it told to me as it is. I would LOVE to quit guessing with all of the limited knowledge I have and finally KNOW.