View Full Version : Micky Mangun Criticized 4 singing of Natl. Anthem
SecretWarrior
02-09-2008, 10:39 AM
Micky Mangun's singing the National Anthem at a recent Governor's event seemed to have stirred a bit of a controversy.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlvAOKESXc8
Monkeyman
02-09-2008, 10:47 AM
Ummm, where is the controversy??
Sarah
02-09-2008, 10:49 AM
Micky Mangun's singing the National Anthem at a recent Governor's event seemed to have stirred a bit of a controversy.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlvAOKESXc8
Did someone complain, Secretwarrior? What was said?
Timmy
02-09-2008, 10:49 AM
What was the controversy about? "Freeeeeeeee... freeeeeeeeee... freeeeeee yeah yayeeeeaaaah"? Or was it the bombs bursting in hair?
Monkeyman
02-09-2008, 10:52 AM
I read the comments on youtube, the critic was cursing at Pentecostals, I think I get it. Hmmmm....something else at work here for sure, Lord help him.
MissBrattified
02-09-2008, 10:54 AM
Um.
Who criticized her, what was said, and how was it controversial? LOL!!!! This video is NOT self-explanatory, so you kind of need to explain yourself SW!!!!!
SecretWarrior
02-09-2008, 10:54 AM
Read the you tube comments
MissBrattified
02-09-2008, 10:55 AM
Oh, I got it, okay.
MissBrattified
02-09-2008, 11:00 AM
Well, I see that a couple of folks were criticizing, and mostly she is being defended.
The comments read more like "Jealous, Bitter & Washed Up needlessly criticizes more successful singer" than anything else. And there are way more defenses than criticism.
I wouldn't say it has stirred up controversy. Just one little, tiny person spewing forth the vomit that comprises his/her heart. What's down in the well comes up in the bucket.
StMark
02-09-2008, 11:02 AM
It can be hard to sing outdoors if the air is dry.
I wonder if she was able to pick the key that the orchestra played in or had to sing in whatever key they chose ?? That would interesting to know.
StMark
02-09-2008, 11:05 AM
Well, I see that a couple of folks were criticizing, and mostly she is being defended.
The comments read more like "Jealous, Bitter & Washed Up needlessly criticizes more successful singer" than anything else. And there are way more defenses than criticism.
I wouldn't say it has stirred up controversy. Just one little, tiny person spewing forth the vomit that comprises his/her heart. What's down in the well comes up in the bucket.
I thought they were very disrespectful- they could have stated their opinion without being ugly. someone is definitley bitter towards Pentecostals.You think maybe they are a member of ExPentecostals.com? :toofunny
MissBrattified
02-09-2008, 11:11 AM
I thought they were very disrespectful- they could have stated their opinion without being ugly. someone is definitley bitter towards Pentecostals.You think maybe they are a member of ExPentecostals.com? :toofunny
Of course! You can say: "I think that could have been done differently" or "I wish she had stuck to the more traditional version" without being mean. :)
Vocally speaking, MM is definitely not perfect, but I still love to hear her sing, mistakes and all!!!
Also, some vocalists do not record well (live), but when you are actually present it may sound a lot different--and feel a lot different.
BoredOutOfMyMind
02-09-2008, 11:11 AM
I wouldn't say it has stirred up controversy. Just one little, tiny person spewing forth the vomit that comprises his/her heart. What's down in the well comes up in the bucket.
I went to great lengths to encode video here so we would not have to dig around in buckets of vomit. Many comments of YouTube videos are unclean at best.
Seems some enjoy throwing muck around more than others. ...
I think You tube needs to disable comments on thier video to keep garbage comments out.
Sad that some people have to resort to vulgar language to comment on a video on you tube.
That being said, I ain't American so I could care less how you guys sing it.
I am old fashioned though, I personally dislike changingin the wording (repeating) or style
of national Anthems.
Mickey still is a great singer!
StMark
02-09-2008, 11:17 AM
Of course! You can say: "I think that could have been done differently" or "I wish she had stuck to the more traditional version" without being mean. :)
Vocally speaking, MM is definitely not perfect, but I still love to hear her sing, mistakes and all!!!
Also, some vocalists do not record well (live), but when you are actually present it may sound a lot different--and feel a lot different.
Stress,age,hormonal changes,health issues,will take an entire step(or more!)off your range.It's hard to lower the key in the National A. simply because it starts so low.
Stress,age,hormonal changes,health issues,will take an entire step(or more!)off your range.It's hard to lower the key in the National A. simply because it starts so low.
So this is what happened to my voice!?
StMark
02-09-2008, 12:45 PM
So this is what happened to my voice!?
HOw am i suppose to know??? post a before an after video
SoCaliUPC
02-09-2008, 01:00 PM
I don't think it was controversial...rather than people think she "butchered" it. Granted...the finale was less to be desired, but that does not take away from the person she is OR the song deemed to be controversial. Hardly controversial.
StMark
02-09-2008, 01:03 PM
I don't think it was controversial...rather than people think she "butchered" it. Granted...the finale was less to be desired, but that does not take away from the person she is OR the song deemed to be controversial. Hardly controversial.
No need to get huffy about it
SoCaliUPC
02-09-2008, 01:04 PM
No need to get huffy about it
That's Terri!!!
I am only commenting that I don't think it was controversial.
George
02-09-2008, 01:05 PM
I am not a fan of Mickey Mangun, but in her defense this did not deserve as harsh criticism it received. Her voice sounds worn and stressed with a little Rod Stewart fibe.
SoCaliUPC
02-09-2008, 01:07 PM
I am not a fan of Mickey Mangun, but in her defense this did not deserve as harsh criticism it received. Her voice sounds worn and stressed with a little Rod Stewart fibe.
Most probably. This was done right after a week of singing at BOTT, where she does a lot of the praise and worship. And as hostess of the conference...sleepless nights as well.
Rhoni
02-09-2008, 01:32 PM
I love to hear MM sing. My fondest memories are "Long and winding road...". Anointing is much more important than ability or 'finesse'.
Blessings, Rhoni
George
02-09-2008, 02:00 PM
I love to hear MM sing. My fondest memories are "Long and winding road...". Anointing is much more important than ability or 'finesse'.
Blessings, Rhoni
Ideal would be to have both finesse and anointing. Not to minimze spirituality, but long time singers reach a point where they become more of a legend and whatever they do - wrong or right - is accepted because of their long term status. I think she is entering that arena.
bethola
02-09-2008, 02:06 PM
I actually joined Youtube so I could post to the "filthy" comment. I'm more of a traditionalist with regard to The National Anthem. Having said that....I don't feel that she "butchered" it anymore than another other singer that has put his or her "spin" on the original version.
MissBrattified
02-09-2008, 02:17 PM
Ideal would be to have both finesse and anointing. Not to minimize spirituality, but long time singers reach a point where they become more of a legend and whatever they do - wrong or right - is accepted because of their long term status. I think she is entering that arena.
George, there are some people I will love to hear sing or preach when they are 95 and can barely get sound out. Finesse is great, but it really isn't all that important, especially in regards to folks who ARE established--simply because we are always going to love them.
Obviously someone really enjoys her singing the national anthem at political events, or they wouldn't keep asking her to do it. Often we are much more critical of our own singers and musicians than secular people.
StillStanding
02-09-2008, 02:36 PM
What was with the free, free, free part? I guess I'm a purist when it comes to the national anthem.
Actually on some notes she screams on pitch. A lot of Apostolic singers have learned to do that quite well! JMHO
StMark
02-09-2008, 03:18 PM
What was with the free, free, free part? I guess I'm a purist when it comes to the national anthem.
Actually on some notes she screams on pitch. A lot of Apostolic singers have learned to do that quite well! JMHO
That was insulting.I'm surprised at you PM.
you need to apologize for that
StillStanding
02-09-2008, 03:29 PM
What was with the free, free, free part? I guess I'm a purist when it comes to the national anthem.
Actually on some notes she screams on pitch. A lot of Apostolic singers have learned to do that quite well! JMHO
That was insulting.I'm surprised at you PM.
you need to apologize for that
What part are you talking about? Are you insulted that I said that she screamed on pitch on a few notes? Should I apologize for my honest opinion?
I honestly believe that many singers have learned to sing quite well by screaming on key on some notes. What's wrong with that?
Actually, I like Sis. Mangun and have enjoyed her singing over the years!
As far as the national athem, I mentioned that I am a purist. I was not impressed with her extra little ditty. I hope you don't take it as a slam on her personally!
George
02-09-2008, 03:32 PM
George, there are some people I will love to hear sing or preach when they are 95 and can barely get sound out. Finesse is great, but it really isn't all that important, especially in regards to folks who ARE established--simply because we are always going to love them.
Obviously someone really enjoys her singing the national anthem at political events, or they wouldn't keep asking her to do it. Often we are much more critical of our own singers and musicians than secular people.
I agree. If they have not "attained," it is best they have anointing and ability. In regards to being more critical of our own, that is normal. It is kind of like parents pushing their children to excel. They don't push the neighbors kids; they push their own. Being critical of our own is often constructive. Please don't misunderstand me. Some criticism is vicious and cannot be used constructively. Overall, you and I are in agreement.
P.S. Most of these legends possessed anointing and great ability in their earlier days which is what caused them to be endeared to us.
Bro-Larry
02-09-2008, 03:38 PM
Micky Mangun's singing the National Anthem at a recent Governor's event seemed to have stirred a bit of a controversy.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlvAOKESXc8
I know first hand how difficult it can be to sing somewhere out of your comfort zone. As for the screaming, that song has such wide range, if you don't start lower than your normal voice, you will likely be screaming when you get to the highest notes.
I loved it.......loved it.......loved it!!! You go Mickey!!!!!
Sarah
02-09-2008, 03:49 PM
I know first hand how difficult it can be to sing somewhere out of your comfort zone. As for the screaming, that song has such wide range, if you don't start lower than your normal voice, you will likely be screaming when you try to hit the highest notes.
I loved it.......loved it.......loved it!!! You go Mickey!!!!!
I loved it too, Big-Larry! Typical MM.
A lot of those people probably know her personally, and have been to the campground in Louisiana, or to their church. Especially the politicians!
AmazingGrace
02-09-2008, 03:49 PM
Old and washed up or whatever some want to call it I still love to hear her sing... Anointed... yep Rhoni... she has it! Hubby drove thru there on the way home from work and picked up her newest CD as they took the first ones out of the box... love it!! No matter how young or how old... she has something special and many love her because she is just Mickey!
Mrs. LPW
02-09-2008, 06:17 PM
I liked the "Free.." and as a Child of God it struck a chord in me.
I've heard so many murder national athems over the years... I don't think she did.
Raven
02-09-2008, 06:43 PM
I wouldn't say it has stirred up controversy. Just one little, tiny person spewing forth the vomit that comprises his/her heart. What's down in the well comes up in the bucket.
MissB
I like your wit and wisdom! You are way beyond your years and a more than worthy opponent to any pseudo-intellectual.
Raven
Cindy
02-09-2008, 06:50 PM
The national anthemn is one of the hardest songs to sing anywhere, anytime. I can't hit the high notes cause I'm an alto. But my youngest can rock that song.
PraiseHymn
02-09-2008, 07:09 PM
Well, at least she did not have any make up and earrings on (LOL)
Bro-Larry
02-09-2008, 07:36 PM
. But my youngest can rock that song.
Right you are Cindy ,she can do it.
SoCaliUPC
02-09-2008, 07:54 PM
I liked the "Free.." and as a Child of God it struck a chord in me.
I've heard so many murder national athems over the years... I don't think she did.
True...she did not murder the song.
SoCaliUPC
02-09-2008, 07:55 PM
Well, at least she did not have any make up and earrings on (LOL)
Yes...Praise the Lord for that!!!! (rolls eyes)
KarenJo
02-09-2008, 08:04 PM
If anyone heard her sing at the dedication for the Clinton Library would know that she can sing the National Anth. very well. There are a lot of reasons for someone to not be at the top of their game. Regardless, she is a great example for POA and the UPC.
Praxeas
02-09-2008, 08:09 PM
It's a PAPIST conspiracy I tell ya! Or maybe the Tulsa 6 had something to do with it. :tease
LordChocolate
02-09-2008, 08:09 PM
If anyone has a problem with her singing the national anthem, they should GET A LIFE!! Life is too short to worry about something like that. Besides, what an honor. If I was good enough, I would do it. Some people are just idiots if they are not the ones doing it.
Sister Alvear
02-09-2008, 09:26 PM
I read the comments...sick people if you ask me...wonder if they could have done better? I doubt it! Whether we like or dislike her singing that is a personal choice it was an honor for her to sing...I would say jealousy is their problem.
StMark
02-09-2008, 09:43 PM
I read the comments...sick people if you ask me...wonder if they could have done better? I doubt it! Whether we like or dislike her singing that is a personal choice it was an honor for her to sing...I would say jealousy is their problem.
Tell it mom !!! Did you hear that PM?????
LaGirl
02-09-2008, 09:53 PM
the Governor is going to be at our church next sunday, maybe i should ask him what he thought? :-)
StMark
02-09-2008, 09:55 PM
the Governor is going to be at our church next sunday, maybe i should ask him what he thought? :-)
DO IT @!!!! :happydance
OH!!!! and did I hear that Dottie Rambo was coming back to a certain UPC church in Louisiana for an encore performance????????????????????????
LaGirl
02-09-2008, 09:58 PM
DO IT @!!!! :happydance
OH!!!! and did I hear that Dottie Rambo was coming back to a certain UPC church in Louisiana for an encore performance????????????????????????
i may have to! lol
not sure if you heard it....but i believe she is coming back to a UPC church in Louisiana!
StMark
02-09-2008, 09:59 PM
i may have to! lol
not sure if you heard it....but i believe she is coming back to a UPC church in Louisiana!
makeup, nail paint, earrings and all ???????????????????
LaGirl
02-09-2008, 09:59 PM
makeup, nail paint, earrings and all ???????????????????
she toned it down when she was with us.
Sister Alvear
02-09-2008, 09:59 PM
Tell it mom !!! Did you hear that PM?????
No just read them...so sad people would stoop so low...blessings to you.
StMark
02-09-2008, 10:01 PM
she toned it down when she was with us.
Give me a run down
Sister Alvear
02-09-2008, 10:03 PM
I will go back and listen...
LaGirl
02-09-2008, 10:04 PM
Give me a run down
a run down of what? didnt u see the pics?
Sister Alvear
02-09-2008, 10:05 PM
Always liked to hear Dottie sing.
LaGirl
02-09-2008, 10:05 PM
Always liked to hear Dottie sing.
she is such a sweet lady.
StMark
02-09-2008, 10:11 PM
a run down of what? didnt u see the pics?
you said she toned it down?? how so? I saw HUGE turqoiuse earrings ,bright red finger nails and painted like an indian ready for war
Sister Alvear
02-09-2008, 10:11 PM
I remember her from a long time ago...I was in the 12th grade the first time I heard them sing...(Buck and Dottie)
LaGirl
02-09-2008, 10:17 PM
you said she toned it down?? how so? I saw HUGE turqoiuse earrings ,bright red finger nails and painted like an indian ready for war
naw.....they said she toned it down some. maybe with her wearing a dress that was toning down.....lol
StMark
02-09-2008, 10:49 PM
I remember her from a long time ago...I was in the 12th grade the first time I heard them sing...(Buck and Dottie)
Reverand Buck??? boy i hear he was quite the preachin' machine :happydance:happydance:happydance:happydance
Ok...I did only got to like page three and then had to comment. You folks...not all just the complainers....sound like a bunch of old women sitting around trying to find something to tear apart. It is really gross they way that happens.... Sis. Mikey Mangun is one of the most anointed, gifted singers in our ranks. She has a style all her own, very distinctive! I personally love her singing. She is, next to my wife, one of my all time favorite singers. Not just her ability, but her passion!
Maybe I am the minority here, but I liked the way she juiced it up a little. I think she was trying to make a point on the 'free' part. I liked it. But, I am not all that traditional......
Come on folks....get out to the rocking chairs and stop all the tearing things down. God really doesn't like that you know! I get so sick of reading it too!
:dance:macho
I liked the "Free.." and as a Child of God it struck a chord in me.
I've heard so many murder national athems over the years... I don't think she did.
Yep...when she sang that....I felt it! Ya know. THAT is probably why she is always asked to do these thing. You don't feel THAT from your average joe...that's for sure!
:stretch:
MissBrattified
02-09-2008, 11:08 PM
Ok...I did only got to like page three and then had to comment. You folks...not all just the complainers....sound like a bunch of old women sitting around trying to find something to tear apart. It is really gross they way that happens.... Sis. Mikey Mangun is one of the most anointed, gifted singers in our ranks. She has a style all her own, very distinctive! I personally love her singing. She is, next to my wife, one of my all time favorite singers. Not just her ability, but her passion!
Maybe I am the minority here, but I liked the way she juiced it up a little. I think she was trying to make a point on the 'free' part. I liked it. But, I am not all that traditional......
Come on folks....get out to the rocking chairs and stop all the tearing things down. God really doesn't like that you know! I get so sick of reading it too!
:dance:macho
Huh? Most of the people here like MM, and are only too ready to defend her. Did you confuse us with the YouTube comments? :coffee2
Huh? Most of the people here like MM, and are only too ready to defend her. Did you confuse us with the YouTube comments? :coffee2
No ma'am....I read the first few pages and it disturbed me!
MissBrattified
02-09-2008, 11:14 PM
No ma'am....I read the first few pages and it disturbed me!
Better read again with your spectacles on, then--there were only a couple of negative comments--the rest were positive and in defense of our beloved Mickey! ;)
Better read again with your spectacles on, then--there were only a couple of negative comments--the rest were positive and in defense of our beloved Mickey! ;)
I've read them... thanks.
AmazingGrace
02-09-2008, 11:44 PM
Ummm, where is the controversy??
Did someone complain, Secretwarrior? What was said?
What was the controversy about? "Freeeeeeeee... freeeeeeeeee... freeeeeee yeah yayeeeeaaaah"? Or was it the bombs bursting in hair?
I read the comments on youtube, the critic was cursing at Pentecostals, I think I get it. Hmmmm....something else at work here for sure, Lord help him.
Um.
Who criticized her, what was said, and how was it controversial? LOL!!!! This video is NOT self-explanatory, so you kind of need to explain yourself SW!!!!!
Read the you tube comments
Oh, I got it, okay.
Well, I see that a couple of folks were criticizing, and mostly she is being defended.
The comments read more like "Jealous, Bitter & Washed Up needlessly criticizes more successful singer" than anything else. And there are way more defenses than criticism.
I wouldn't say it has stirred up controversy. Just one little, tiny person spewing forth the vomit that comprises his/her heart. What's down in the well comes up in the bucke
It can be hard to sing outdoors if the air is dry.
I wonder if she was able to pick the key that the orchestra played in or had to sing in whatever key they chose ?? That would interesting to know.
Ok.......... that is every post from page one... JR show me where one of our posters criticized her??????
AmazingGrace
02-09-2008, 11:48 PM
I thought they were very disrespectful- they could have stated their opinion without being ugly. someone is definitley bitter towards Pentecostals.You think maybe they are a member of ExPentecostals.com?
Of course! You can say: "I think that could have been done differently" or "I wish she had stuck to the more traditional version" without being mean.
Vocally speaking, MM is definitely not perfect, but I still love to hear her sing, mistakes and all!!!
Also, some vocalists do not record well (live), but when you are actually present it may sound a lot different--and feel a lot different.
I went to great lengths to encode video here so we would not have to dig around in buckets of vomit. Many comments of YouTube videos are unclean at best.
Seems some enjoy throwing muck around more than others. ...
I think You tube needs to disable comments on thier video to keep garbage comments out.
Sad that some people have to resort to vulgar language to comment on a video on you tube.
That being said, I ain't American so I could care less how you guys sing it.
I am old fashioned though, I personally dislike changingin the wording (repeating) or style
of national Anthems.
Mickey still is a great singer!
Stress,age,hormonal changes,health issues,will take an entire step(or more!)off your range.It's hard to lower the key in the National A. simply because it starts so low.
So this is what happened to my voice!?
HOw am i suppose to know??? post a before an after video
I don't think it was controversial...rather than people think she "butchered" it. Granted...the finale was less to be desired, but that does not take away from the person she is OR the song deemed to be controversial. Hardly controversial.
No need to get huffy about it
That's Terri!!!
I am only commenting that I don't think it was controversial
Hmmm Now I am thru page 2 and still dont see nothing
Dude Jr person... this isnt that other forum.. everyone here is not out to get someone else... we all pretty much said we liked or loved her singing and that it wasnt necessary what was said in the comments on youtube.. think you need to get a new set of glasses or something... get over it! We are all on the same page
AmazingGrace
02-09-2008, 11:48 PM
I've read them... thanks.
Get a grip!
Sister Alvear
02-09-2008, 11:49 PM
I can't even imagine the pressure someone would feel at such an event...MY Blessings to her.
AmazingGrace
02-09-2008, 11:54 PM
I am not a fan of Mickey Mangun, but in her defense this did not deserve as harsh criticism it received. Her voice sounds worn and stressed with a little Rod Stewart fibe.
(my comments here... Oh I guess this is the harsh criticism??? ROFL.. whatever.... is it a sin to say we dont like someones singing? No... this isnt harsh nor a thing wrong with it... he has an opinion that he doesnt care for her style.. its nothing like what was said on the youtube... )
Most probably. This was done right after a week of singing at BOTT, where she does a lot of the praise and worship. And as hostess of the conference...sleepless nights as well.
I love to hear MM sing. My fondest memories are "Long and winding road...". Anointing is much more important than ability or 'finesse'.
Blessings, Rhoni
Ideal would be to have both finesse and anointing. Not to minimze spirituality, but long time singers reach a point where they become more of a legend and whatever they do - wrong or right - is accepted because of their long term status. I think she is entering that arena.
actually joined Youtube so I could post to the "filthy" comment. I'm more of a traditionalist with regard to The National Anthem. Having said that....I don't feel that she "butchered" it anymore than another other singer that has put his or her "spin" on the original version.
George, there are some people I will love to hear sing or preach when they are 95 and can barely get sound out. Finesse is great, but it really isn't all that important, especially in regards to folks who ARE established--simply because we are always going to love them.
Obviously someone really enjoys her singing the national anthem at political events, or they wouldn't keep asking her to do it. Often we are much more critical of our own singers and musicians than secular people.
What was with the free, free, free part? I guess I'm a purist when it comes to the national anthem.
Actually on some notes she screams on pitch. A lot of Apostolic singers have learned to do that quite well! JMHO
That was insulting.I'm surprised at you PM.
you need to apologize for that
What part are you talking about? Are you insulted that I said that she screamed on pitch on a few notes? Should I apologize for my honest opinion?
I honestly believe that many singers have learned to sing quite well by screaming on key on some notes. What's wrong with that?
Actually, I like Sis. Mangun and have enjoyed her singing over the years!
As far as the national athem, I mentioned that I am a purist. I was not impressed with her extra little ditty. I hope you don't take it as a slam on her personally!
I agree. If they have not "attained," it is best they have anointing and ability. In regards to being more critical of our own, that is normal. It is kind of like parents pushing their children to excel. They don't push the neighbors kids; they push their own. Being critical of our own is often constructive. Please don't misunderstand me. Some criticism is vicious and cannot be used constructively. Overall, you and I are in agreement.
P.S. Most of these legends possessed anointing and great ability in their earlier days which is what caused them to be endeared to us.
So there were a few who voiced they didnt like something different being done with the anthem... thats fine...they arent tearing her down... get over yourself.. not everyone is gonna care for her or like her singing... one or 2 people said something about not caring for it and you get in a tizzy... 99% of us said we loved it and her....
StMark
02-10-2008, 12:02 AM
sounds like someone is off on a tangent tonight
AmazingGrace
02-10-2008, 12:03 AM
Who??? Me or him???
StMark
02-10-2008, 12:05 AM
Who??? Me or him???
No names but the gender is felmale
AmazingGrace
02-10-2008, 12:07 AM
No names but the gender is felmale
Nope not a tangent... just showing him he is sadly mistaken... I hate people coming in here once in a blue moon and calling others liars! Hate it!
Everyone here defended her and then he comes in and says otherwise... so now you got your tangent... happy? I love her and love her singing... listening to hr newest cd right now and tired of people actin a fool!
StMark
02-10-2008, 12:10 AM
Nope not a tangent... just showing him he is sadly mistaken... I hate people coming in here once in a blue moon and calling others liars! Hate it!
Everyone here defended her and then he comes in and says otherwise... so now you got your tangent... happy? I love her and love her singing... listening to hr newest cd right now and tired of people actin a fool!
Jr?? you can't let this one slip by you
AmazingGrace
02-10-2008, 12:14 AM
Thing is Mark ... he left... some people arent strong enough to post something like this and then stay around and defend themselves... they like to post and run... its easier that way ya know?!?!
StMark
02-10-2008, 12:20 AM
Thing is Mark ... he left... some people arent strong enough to post something like this and then stay around and defend themselves... they like to post and run... its easier that way ya know?!?!
oh he'll be back at some point. Jr is not the type to let something go believe me
AmazingGrace
02-10-2008, 12:21 AM
oh he'll be back at some point. Jr is not the type to let something go believe me
Good because that is the one thing that makes me lose all respect of a poster faster than anything else!
Bro-Larry
02-10-2008, 09:44 AM
you said she toned it down?? how so? I saw HUGE turqoiuse earrings ,bright red finger nails and painted like an indian ready for war
What ever happened to Buck?
rgcraig
02-10-2008, 10:23 AM
This is all I'll say about it - - I think when singing with a band you almost need to follow them. I wonder if she just threw that in live or if they had practiced it that way.
Had she had an organist that could have followed her like in a church service, the free, free, free would have worked better.
Mrs. LPW
02-10-2008, 11:20 AM
you said she toned it down?? how so? I saw HUGE turqoiuse earrings ,bright red finger nails and painted like an indian ready for war
:toofunny
I like the way you put things sometimes StMark!
Mrs. LPW
02-10-2008, 11:22 AM
Ok...I did only got to like page three and then had to comment. You folks...not all just the complainers....sound like a bunch of old women sitting around trying to find something to tear apart. It is really gross they way that happens.... Sis. Mikey Mangun is one of the most anointed, gifted singers in our ranks. She has a style all her own, very distinctive! I personally love her singing. She is, next to my wife, one of my all time favorite singers. Not just her ability, but her passion!
Maybe I am the minority here, but I liked the way she juiced it up a little. I think she was trying to make a point on the 'free' part. I liked it. But, I am not all that traditional......
Come on folks....get out to the rocking chairs and stop all the tearing things down. God really doesn't like that you know! I get so sick of reading it too!
:dance:macho
that's nice of you to say about your wife..
and the rocking chair comment sounds like something Monkeyman would say HA
I think MOST posters on here were defending Mickey's rendition... and personally, I don't think anyone should comment on someone's singing if they can't sing themselves (course most that can't sing, don't know they can't :toofunny)
StillStanding
02-10-2008, 06:18 PM
I don't mind listening to the national anthem in different vocal styles. In fact, this year I heard Take Six sing the anthem in a jazz style as only they can do. It was awesome! I've heard it sung with different levels of vocal acrobatics, which I was fine with.
For some reason, I don't care to hear the national anthem done with gospel type liberties. This is one area where I believe in a separation of church and state! :)
This is nothing against Sis. Mangun. I think she is a great gospel singer who sings with "ointment"! :D
Well, I see that a couple of folks were criticizing, and mostly she is being defended.
The comments read more like "Jealous, Bitter & Washed Up needlessly criticizes more successful singer" than anything else. And there are way more defenses than criticism.
I wouldn't say it has stirred up controversy. Just one little, tiny person spewing forth the vomit that comprises his/her heart. What's down in the well comes up in the bucket.
...Vance Havner.... I love his quotes!
ForeverBlessed
02-18-2008, 12:25 PM
Stress,age,hormonal changes,health issues,will take an entire step(or more!)off your range.It's hard to lower the key in the National A. simply because it starts so low.
I agree... many things can factor into throwing off your range. M.M. is a great singer... too bad people are so mean.
I sang the National Anthem at Indiana Republican State Convention back in the 90's... and it was extremely nerve wracking to me...
I was 9 months pregnant w/ my youngest child... and had the national guard marching in front of me and the 10K plus delegates.... and every stinkin' Indiana politician behind me...
I had a lot of people come up to me with compliments and MUCH admiration for singing it while that huge/prego... lol I will say being pregnant does effect breathing.
Sarah
02-18-2008, 12:50 PM
I agree... many things can factor into throwing off your range. M.M. is a great singer... too bad people are so mean.
I sang the National Anthem at Indiana Republican State Convention back in the 90's... and it was extremely nerve wracking to me...
I was 9 months pregnant w/ my youngest child... and had the national guard marching in front of me and the 10K plus delegates.... and every stinkin' Indiana politician behind me...
I had a lot of people come up to me with compliments and MUCH admiration for singing it while that huge/prego... lol I will say being pregnant does effect breathing.
What an honor for you!
I would love to see a video of that.
pastorswife
02-18-2008, 01:43 PM
Micky Mangun's singing the National Anthem at a recent Governor's event seemed to have stirred a bit of a controversy.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlvAOKESXc8
Wow I think she did a good job. :scoregood
pastorswife
02-18-2008, 01:45 PM
The Free the free part really made it have more feeling to it. As if that song needs someting added to make you feel something. :shockamoo:shockamoo
MissBrattified
02-18-2008, 01:54 PM
I have to say, of all the songs I might sing, singing the National Anthem would NOT be one of my picks. Add a formal band, outdoors and live? NO WAY!!!! I've heard some of the best singers really butcher that song--and MM wasn't one of them.
The "free, free, free" wasn't my favorite thing--I like sticking with more traditional versions--but it wasn't as ruinous as the youtube poster wanted everyone to think, or as some on here have stated.
In reference to singing in general: Simplicity is way underrated.
ForeverBlessed
02-18-2008, 02:17 PM
I have to say, of all the songs I might sing, singing the National Anthem would NOT be one of my picks. Add a formal band, outdoors and live? NO WAY!!!! I've heard some of the best singers really butcher that song--and MM wasn't one of them.
The "free, free, free" wasn't my favorite thing--I like sticking with more traditional versions--but it wasn't as ruinous as the youtube poster wanted everyone to think, or as some on here have stated.
In reference to singing in general: Simplicity is way underrated.
I agree with you.. I like traditional in those types of settings...
The vocal quality and unconventional style will still show through..... but I stuck to the more traditional... just a little soul at the end...but didn't do no "free,free,free" stuff... I will leave that to choir songs... lol
ForeverBlessed
02-18-2008, 02:29 PM
What an honor for you!
I would love to see a video of that.
I have pictures, but no personal video of it... it was Summer of 1992..
We didn't buy a personal camcorder until after Bekah was born... actually Christmas of 92.
Monkeyman
02-25-2008, 06:54 PM
Her mistake was to sing with a marching band..the only singers I have ever heard pull that off correctly was Fleetwood Mac...and of course the world's BEST marching band, USC USC USC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If she would have used a soundtrack, she would have pulled off the "free, free, freeeeeeeee" better, it was the bands fault, not hers IMO.
NewWine
03-03-2008, 04:19 PM
:usaI browsed over some of the comments by YouTube members, and some were just downright nasty. But, you have to ignore people. Some will say anything to get a rise out of people. For some reason some tried to make this a 'Pentecostal' issue; which it is not. I have two opinions in regards to Sis. Mangun's singing the National Anthem.
First, singing the National Anthem is not as easy as some deem it to be. It is unknown whether or not she was able to practice with the band/orchestra; which makes a difference. Having played in orchestras from elementary to junior college I can understand that; and have been in that position. Sometimes having a 'feel' for the musical style of the singer, helps out tremendously. It is just up to the musicians to follow the lead of the singer. She sang the song they way she felt to sing it. It was not my personal liking, however, music is interpreted by each person differently.
Secondly, we (Apostolics) see so many sing the National Anthem that don't even believe in God and would do anything to remove our right to worship Jesus Christ freely. Let me repeat that freely......freely.....freely. So, it was nice to someone of precious like faith sing the National Anthem. Seeing as how our nation was founded on Christianity; it is nice to have see a TRUE CHRISTIAN, sing the National Anthem. I look at her singing more symbolically than how the performance went.
Respectfully :) NewWine
MissBrattified
03-03-2008, 04:21 PM
NewWine, that font size is hurting my eyes! :coffee2
vBulletin® v3.8.5, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.