PDA

View Full Version : The Wizard Behind the Curtain


ILG
09-04-2010, 08:52 AM
I remember being in the world before the UPC. I felt the injustice of many things and saw the structure of the world and how it favored some over others and gave perks to some over others that didn't deserve it, that perhaps slimed their way up, or, often were simply born into their silver spoon status.

I was raised poor, with an alcoholic father who had been the illegitimate son of a 16 year old raped girl. My Dad was later adopted by a divorced man who married my grandmother. They had four more children. They worked a farm and all slept in the upstairs of a house that grew huge icicles on the inside in the winter and dripped on them in the spring. They divorced after my Dad moved out because my grandfather was having an affair and threw my aunt on the floor when she confronted him about it.

My mother grew up materially poor in a family of 14 children. They ate molasses sandwiches and slept many to a bed, covered with coats and blankets for warmth. My mother gave her cousin an empty spool of thread for her birthday. My grandfather was a commerical seasonal fisherman. My grandmother used to cry in the outhouse because she had so many children and did not want anymore, but the Catholic church did not believe in birth control and my grandfather always said "God will provide".

Compared to my parents, I grew up well off, in a house with wood heat that didn't drip on me. We had a real toilet that flushed. I got two new outfits for school every year and if we were lucky, on our back to school trip, we were allowed a cheesburger at McDonalds. (No happy meals as they were too expensive.) We ate venison and fish and garden produce.

My mother used to sing in bars when I was young and us kids often went. I talked to many a drunk on a barstool. My brother and I would stick our arms up into the pool table and pull the balls out because we didn't have any quarters to play pool. My Mom and Dad would fight as my Mom would want to go home after a while and my Dad would want to stay. My Dad used to give me peppermint schnapps on the rocks when I was young. I got drunk first at age 12 and continued the pattern until I was 19.

I saw much injustice in the world. I saw how people who were born into perfect (to me) families had it knocked. I saw how they knew the rules and they knew how to use them to their advantage. I saw how they got all the perks at school and how they were popular and how they got good grades, nice clothes, cars, money and perks.

I did some of that stuff. But I had to work very hard for whatever I got, because it was never handed on a silver platter. I had to learn the rules for myself and earn my keep.

ILG
09-04-2010, 08:55 AM
More to come...

ILG
09-04-2010, 09:24 AM
The injustice I felt went deep. I had a young bitterness about the world and how it was run. I resented the people who looked down on the less fortunate as somehow lesser people.

When I was 19, I got into the church. The experience with God was wonderful and marvelous. It was like nothing I ever felt. "Come with us" , the people said "We have a different system, a different way of life where we care about people. God is no respector of persons. He loves all people. We also believe we should not be respectors of persons".

I loved this message. A God who loved all men equally and did not put one above the other. A system that was like God. I was in heaven.

Many, many promises were made to me through preaching and teaching about God and his church and how things were so mush better, so much different here. My family was concerned about me. They felt I was falling for a line. Some of them called me brainwashed. I blew them all off. What did they know? They did not have the experience I had and I knew how they lived. I had a new life and I was whole hog, hook, line and sinker.

I began to see little things that bothered me, but the message was too good. The experience was too good. The promises were too good. We forged ahead my husband and I, convinced our calling was to take this message to the world. We worked very, very hard, starting a church, advertising, passing out tracts, teaching bible studies, paying for it all and getting no respect and very little help.

Meanwhile, we saw pastors sons given pastorates and silver spoons placed in their mouths. We decided they didn't know what we knew and we knew our message was too important to not pass it on. People are worthwhile no matter who they are and God loves them all. We forged ahead while pastors canvassed in our area and took people from us with promises of big choirs and lots of people. We forged ahead while we were warned not to steal any people from anyone. We forged ahead while we were told to contribute to every program so they could know we were cooperating with them. We forged ahead while they missed sending us Home Missions checks and refused to let us sell baked goods in their churches at Home Missions rallies. We forged ahead while I went to ladies retreats alone, believing the message. We forged ahead and paid the bills mostly alone.

We forged ahead while they told us our families were going to hell and while they made excuses for their own. We forged ahead while we believed the messages and they watered it down.

Finally, we believed we needed to move to a larger church because we were burned out. When we moved to the larger church, we found there were no income records and money spent on the previous pastors personal things. When we took this to the church, many did not believe us. Still, we forged ahead, believing the message. The district board shoved it all under the rug. Still we forged ahead, believing the message. But, the veil was being lifted.

In time, after a shocking personal revelation.....I stopped believing the message. It was about standards at first. I could not believe I had been lied to and duped for 16 years. Pants were not men's apparel. The Bible didn't say women couldn't cut their hair, etc.

But the core message to me stayed the same. God loves all people the same. Injustice should be fought against. We continued to fight, believing this message.

But, when I said standards were not biblical and mentioned all the injustices, I was told we are all human and that this is a human problem, not a UPC one. What? After all the promises I was made about us being the church? What? After all the times I was told that God is no respector of persons? What? After believing standards lies for years, I now find out I believed another one? That the church is just as guilty as everyone else regarding these things?

And indeed, I found out that the church is just as guilty. For as much as it postures itself as being God's people and as much as it says it is better than others and has "the truth", that it is a better way to live, that it is the right way, the only way, the only way not to burn in hell, I find out that it isn't true.

Yes, the problems are human problems. The veil has been lifted. The Wizard of Oz is actually behind the curtain just making things look powerful, incredible and amazing, when the God that they claim exclusive rights to, is actually everywhere and a real promoter of justice and truly, no respector of persons. He is the One I have been serving all along.

I don't go to church anymore. Not often anyway. I keep seeing Wizards behind curtains. I don't know if that will ever change. But, the God I believe in, the God that saved me, I believe that He still believes in justice, in love, in not being a respector of persons and that someday, He will make all this right. He is the God I love and the One I follow. I believe He is not a Wizard behind a curtain.

ILG
09-04-2010, 09:25 AM
Thank you!

Mr. Smith
09-04-2010, 12:27 PM
Thank you!



Thank you for writing.

Those that take the time to read may say you're bitter, painting with a broad brush....the cliches are always the same. But your words are loudly heard.

Thanks again.

nahkoe
09-04-2010, 12:42 PM
I struggle with the wizards behind the curtains too. It's difficult to separate God from the Christianity that's all over the place...the Christianity I refuse to have anything to do with.

iceniez
09-04-2010, 01:17 PM
Very interesting, I don't have much faith in the Machine , I do believe it is broken , and in need of repair..... But still there is hope God is different , He is not a man and can't lie. We have to please him,and Him alone .I am trying to learn that and how to do that. { according to what He teaches me in his word } Not based on religion, or tradition.The hard part is being looked at as sinners by those who say they are Christian [ apostolic ] because we don't fit in.

Sarah
09-04-2010, 01:35 PM
The injustice I felt went deep. I had a young bitterness about the world and how it was run. I resented the people who looked down on the less fortunate as somehow lesser people.

When I was 19, I got into the church. The experience with God was wonderful and marvelous. It was like nothing I ever felt. "Come with us" , the people said "We have a different system, a different way of life where we care about people. God is no respector of persons. He loves all people. We also believe we should not be respectors of persons".

I loved this message. A God who loved all men equally and did not put one above the other. A system that was like God. I was in heaven.

Many, many promises were made to me through preaching and teaching about God and his church and how things were so mush better, so much different here. My family was concerned about me. They felt I was falling for a line. Some of them called me brainwashed. I blew them all off. What did they know? They did not have the experience I had and I knew how they lived. I had a new life and I was whole hog, hook, line and sinker.

I began to see little things that bothered me, but the message was too good. The experience was too good. The promises were too good. We forged ahead my husband and I, convinced our calling was to take this message to the world. We worked very, very hard, starting a church, advertising, passing out tracts, teaching bible studies, paying for it all and getting no respect and very little help.

Meanwhile, we saw pastors sons given pastorates and silver spoons placed in their mouths. We decided they didn't know what we knew and we knew our message was too important to not pass it on. People are worthwhile no matter who they are and God loves them all. We forged ahead while pastors canvassed in our area and took people from us with promises of big choirs and lots of people. We forged ahead while we were warned not to steal any people from anyone. We forged ahead while we were told to contribute to every program so they could know we were cooperating with them. We forged ahead while they missed sending us Home Missions checks and refused to let us sell baked goods in their churches at Home Missions rallies. We forged ahead while I went to ladies retreats alone, believing the message. We forged ahead and paid the bills mostly alone.

We forged ahead while they told us our families were going to hell and while they made excuses for their own. We forged ahead while we believed the messages and they watered it down.

Finally, we believed we needed to move to a larger church because we were burned out. When we moved to the larger church, we found there were no income records and money spent on the previous pastors personal things. When we took this to the church, many did not believe us. Still, we forged ahead, believing the message. The district board shoved it all under the rug. Still we forged ahead, believing the message. But, the veil was being lifted.

In time, after a shocking personal revelation.....I stopped believing the message. It was about standards at first. I could not believe I had been lied to and duped for 16 years. Pants were not men's apparel. The Bible didn't say women couldn't cut their hair, etc.

But the core message to me stayed the same. God loves all people the same. Injustice should be fought against. We continued to fight, believing this message.

But, when I said standards were not biblical and mentioned all the injustices, I was told we are all human and that this is a human problem, not a UPC one. What? After all the promises I was made about us being the church? What? After all the times I was told that God is no respector of persons? What? After believing standards lies for years, I now find out I believed another one? That the church is just as guilty as everyone else regarding these things?

And indeed, I found out that the church is just as guilty. For as much as it postures itself as being God's people and as much as it says it is better than others and has "the truth", that it is a better way to live, that it is the right way, the only way, the only way not to burn in hell, I find out that it isn't true.

Yes, the problems are human problems. The veil has been lifted. The Wizard of Oz is actually behind the curtain just making things look powerful, incredible and amazing, when the God that they claim exclusive rights to, is actually everywhere and a real promoter of justice and truly, no respector of persons. He is the One I have been serving all along.

I don't go to church anymore. Not often anyway. I keep seeing Wizards behind curtains. I don't know if that will ever change. But, the God I believe in, the God that saved me, I believe that He still believes in justice, in love, in not being a respector of persons and that someday, He will make all this right. He is the God I love and the One I follow. I believe He is not a Wizard behind a curtain.


ILG, I was feeling an overwhelming helplessness while reading this, 'til I got to the last paragraph. He's not a respector of person, dear....and He WILL make it all right! I believe you really desire that.

I'd like to offer a suggestion. Get off the computer, get alone and pray, and ask God to direct you to a church in your area. He never fails!

I've read your posts for several years now, and my heart has always gone out to you. I pray for you...

Sam
09-04-2010, 01:53 PM
...
I'd like to offer a suggestion. Get off the computer, get alone and pray, and ask God to direct you to a church in your area. He never fails!

I've read your posts for several years now, and my heart has always gone out to you. I pray for you...

But if God "leads" ILG to a "trinity" church, some of us would really think that was wrong.

Dedicated Mind
09-04-2010, 02:30 PM
Good words ILG. Do you think there is a role for churches in the salvation of the lost or have you given up on churches altogether?

Pro31:28
09-04-2010, 02:36 PM
ILG,

Beautiful, transparent post. I feel your pain, and while our course was somewhat different, I understand. I remember thinking to myself whenever doubt would appear "but these men who I love and respect believe and preach it, so it has to be true!".

We are now in a church that we absolutely love, but I will tell you something, transparency is what makes this church unique. Our pastor and assistant pastor make no bones about the fact that they are fallible, and so money records are always accessible and they are always wanting ideas.

I really appreciate what you wrote and I am praying for you, for your hurt, and for all of the people who let you down (my childhood and yours have much in common). God has plan, and often fallible people are a part of it, but through it all He adores us, and the fact that you are here and seeking cyber fellowship with us liberals is a great thing- YOU GO GIRL!!! I got your back

Praxeas
09-04-2010, 03:17 PM
But if God "leads" ILG to a "trinity" church, some of us would really think that was wrong.
some of you.

I have a friend that goes to a trinitarian church. The reason is she moved up north and went to an Apostolic church and told the pastor why she left the UPC she was attending down here. The issue was her disagreement over standards. She told the pastor she would comply with his teaching and obey, but the Pastor wanted nothing of it.

Now she goes to an AOG, still believes in baptism in Jesus name and Oneness.

On the other hand there is a newer UPC in the area and she has gotten to be friends with the Pastor. So far that pastor has not tried to rebuke her or convince her she is a sinner but has been very friendly in return.

Sorry but sometimes these kinds of threads to appear to be broadbrush in general, though that may not be the intent.

It's not synonymous with Apostolic or Oneness. It happens in Apostolic or Oneness churches. It also happens in Trinitarian churches

Mr. Smith
09-04-2010, 03:59 PM
Thank you for writing.

Those that take the time to read may say you're bitter, painting with a broad brush....the cliches are always the same. But your words are loudly heard.

Thanks again.

some of you.

I have a friend that goes to a trinitarian church. The reason is she moved up north and went to an Apostolic church and told the pastor why she left the UPC she was attending down here. The issue was her disagreement over standards. She told the pastor she would comply with his teaching and obey, but the Pastor wanted nothing of it.

Now she goes to an AOG, still believes in baptism in Jesus name and Oneness.

On the other hand there is a newer UPC in the area and she has gotten to be friends with the Pastor. So far that pastor has not tried to rebuke her or convince her she is a sinner but has been very friendly in return.

Sorry but sometimes these kinds of threads to appear to be broadbrush in general, though that may not be the intent.

It's not synonymous with Apostolic or Oneness. It happens in Apostolic or Oneness churches. It also happens in Trinitarian churches


I think I'm gonna change my name from "Mr. Smith" to "Prophet Smith".

ILG
09-04-2010, 04:09 PM
Thank you for writing.

Those that take the time to read may say you're bitter, painting with a broad brush....the cliches are always the same. But your words are loudly heard.

Thanks again.

Thanks Mr. Smith. I am well aware of the "bitterness" accusations and I feel I am past all that. I really don't care anymore. It's just more smoke and mirrors.

ILG
09-04-2010, 04:10 PM
I struggle with the wizards behind the curtains too. It's difficult to separate God from the Christianity that's all over the place...the Christianity I refuse to have anything to do with.

Yes, indeed, it is.

ILG
09-04-2010, 04:12 PM
Very interesting, I don't have much faith in the Machine , I do believe it is broken , and in need of repair..... But still there is hope God is different , He is not a man and can't lie. We have to please him,and Him alone .I am trying to learn that and how to do that. { according to what He teaches me in his word } Not based on religion, or tradition.The hard part is being looked at as sinners by those who say they are Christian [ apostolic ] because we don't fit in.

It's hard at first, but it gets easier in time. I never fit in anyway, and many never have. Really, that's a large part of what I am writing about. After a while, you kind of give up trying to fit in. What are people trying to fit into anyway and is it worth it? Those are the real questions.

ILG
09-04-2010, 04:14 PM
ILG, I was feeling an overwhelming helplessness while reading this, 'til I got to the last paragraph. He's not a respector of person, dear....and He WILL make it all right! I believe you really desire that.

I'd like to offer a suggestion. Get off the computer, get alone and pray, and ask God to direct you to a church in your area. He never fails!

I've read your posts for several years now, and my heart has always gone out to you. I pray for you...

I appreciate the prayers, but I'll leave the advice, as well intended as I know it is. ;)

ILG
09-04-2010, 04:19 PM
But if God "leads" ILG to a "trinity" church, some of us would really think that was wrong.

LOL! For sure!

ILG
09-04-2010, 04:25 PM
Good words ILG. Do you think there is a role for churches in the salvation of the lost or have you given up on churches altogether?

Yes, I guess maybe. But I do not feel at all called to be involved in it anymore. I don't understand all the ins and outs of all that and don't claim to, which is one reason I don't try and tell people how to run their lives. I strongly felt and believed I was supposed to be where I was back when I was doing the things I was doing (although I question a lot of that now). I think people largely have to find their own way and figure things out for themselves, which is why I would not tell people to quit church or anything like that. On the flipside, I expect the same respect for my journey and choices.

Praxeas
09-04-2010, 04:26 PM
I think I'm gonna change my name from "Mr. Smith" to "Prophet Smith".
And? Did u get it all?
I said these kinds of threads appear to generalize. That's my honest opinion. I didn't say she did, but most often that is how they appear. It may not be the initial poster, but some later responding in generalizations. I was in fact respondig to what you said.

ILG
09-04-2010, 04:27 PM
ILG,

Beautiful, transparent post. I feel your pain, and while our course was somewhat different, I understand. I remember thinking to myself whenever doubt would appear "but these men who I love and respect believe and preach it, so it has to be true!".

We are now in a church that we absolutely love, but I will tell you something, transparency is what makes this church unique. Our pastor and assistant pastor make no bones about the fact that they are fallible, and so money records are always accessible and they are always wanting ideas.

I really appreciate what you wrote and I am praying for you, for your hurt, and for all of the people who let you down (my childhood and yours have much in common). God has plan, and often fallible people are a part of it, but through it all He adores us, and the fact that you are here and seeking cyber fellowship with us liberals is a great thing- YOU GO GIRL!!! I got your back

Thanks Pro31:28. I appreciate your words. I'm glad you are happy where you are.

ILG
09-04-2010, 04:32 PM
It also happens in Trinitarian churches

Yeah. We were going to a trinitarian church for a while. I kept seeing the wizard behind the curtain there too. That's my point. It really is a people problem. The sad part was all the promises that were made about being special to God and all that. We were no more special than the next guy.

Hoovie
09-04-2010, 04:47 PM
Yeah. We were going to a trinitarian church for a while. I kept seeing the wizard behind the curtain there too. That's my point. It really is a people problem. The sad part was all the promises that were made about being special to God and all that. We were no more special than the next guy.

ILG, I just read this thread! Once again, my heart goes out to you and your dilemma. It really IS a people problem. Not everyone is nice.

I'll say a prayer for you. If nothing else I hope you find a bit of peace in your current turmoil.

Bless you! :thumbsup

ILG
09-04-2010, 04:48 PM
ILG, I just read this thread! Once again, my heart goes out to you and your dilemma. It really IS a people problem. Not everyone is nice.

I'll say a prayer for you. If nothing else I hope you find a bit of peace in your current turmoil.

Bless you! :thumbsup

Umm, what current turmoil?

Hoovie
09-04-2010, 04:56 PM
Yes, the problems are human problems. The veil has been lifted. The Wizard of Oz is actually behind the curtain just making things look powerful, incredible and amazing, when the God that they claim exclusive rights to, is actually everywhere and a real promoter of justice and truly, no respector of persons. He is the One I have been serving all along.

I don't go to church anymore. Not often anyway. I keep seeing Wizards behind curtains. I don't know if that will ever change. But, the God I believe in, the God that saved me, I believe that He still believes in justice, in love, in not being a respector of persons and that someday, He will make all this right. He is the God I love and the One I follow. I believe He is not a Wizard behind a curtain.

Umm, what current turmoil?

It has to be troubling when those who are to be our spiritual leaders are exposed as disingenuous or even worse frauds themselves. I have not experienced anything that extreme, and I am sorry for you.

ILG
09-04-2010, 05:01 PM
It has to be troubling when those who are to be our spiritual leaders are exposed as disingenuous or even worse frauds themselves. I have not experienced anything that extreme, and I am sorry for you.

Well, it happened quite a long time ago. We left five years ago and it was very hard to do, but I am so much better off and so much happier. I very much enjoy writing and I write about what I know and what people can relate to.

I'm glad you have not experienced anything that extreme but many have. I will take all the prayers I can get, I am certainly not opposed to that.

ManOfWord
09-04-2010, 07:23 PM
Great post! I didn't read any bitterness or vitriol. You were honest, straight forward and to the point. The point is that "what God ordains, man profanes!" The problem is that too many men don't believe that. They believe that THEY are ordained and therefore are God's mouthpiece and are not to be questioned etc. Certainly not all and hopefully not most. But unfortunately, this story is not isolated to ILG. :D

crakjak
09-04-2010, 07:23 PM
The earth is the Lord's and all that is in it. God is at work in the whole earth, all are His creation, ultimately He will not lose any.

Seekers always run up against the people problem, eventually the only answer is one's own relationship with God. Religion will condemn this fact, because the house of cards comes crashing down when one comes to this true.

I go to church, but it is a really different community of believers, flawed, but seeking to follow Jesus. We don't believe that we are the only Christians, rather we are Christians only.

Michael
09-04-2010, 07:30 PM
But if God "leads" ILG to a "trinity" church, some of us would really think that was wrong.

God will never lead someone to a trinity church....Only Sam will.:toofunny

ILG
09-04-2010, 09:07 PM
Great post! I didn't read any bitterness or vitriol. You were honest, straight forward and to the point. The point is that "what God ordains, man profanes!" The problem is that too many men don't believe that. They believe that THEY are ordained and therefore are God's mouthpiece and are not to be questioned etc. Certainly not all and hopefully not most. But unfortunately, this story is not isolated to ILG. :D

Thanks, MOW, glad you enjoyed it! I appreciate the positive feedback!

Margies3
09-04-2010, 10:14 PM
God will never lead someone to a trinity church....Only Sam will.:toofunny

Good grief. So you know everything little thing that God will do? I'm sorry. I just get tired of this sort of attitude. I guess you must be amongst the very small group who are going to be in Heaven for eternity, eh?

You know, I very rarely ever post this sort of come-back to someone. Maybe I'm just cranky tonight.......... oh well, I think I'll leave it here anyway. I saw that you put the smiley at the end. So I am really hoping that that was your attempt at humor. If so, I apologize for jumping on your case.

Hoovie
09-04-2010, 10:18 PM
Margie, I think Mikey is messin with us!

Sam
09-04-2010, 10:19 PM
Good grief. So you know everything little thing that God will do? I'm sorry. I just get tired of this sort of attitude. I guess you must be amongst the very small group who are going to be in Heaven for eternity, eh?

You know, I very rarely ever post this sort of come-back to someone. Maybe I'm just cranky tonight.......... oh well, I think I'll leave it here anyway. I saw that you put the smiley at the end. So I am really hoping that that was your attempt at humor. If so, I apologize for jumping on your case.

relax, Margies3, I was not offended by that.

Margies3
09-04-2010, 10:21 PM
Margie, I think Mikey is messin with us!

relax, Margies3, I was not offended by that.

Ok, thanks, guys, for the correction. Mike, please accept my apologies. Must be those female hormones kicking in. Oh wait! I'm too old for hormones. Those are for 20 year olds, right? LOL Maybe I'm just overly tired. Good night.

CC1
09-05-2010, 08:06 AM
Algae,

I am getting ready for church so have only had time to read your posts and just a few of other peoples responses.

First of all your family's history has made me once again so thankful for being raised in a good Christian home. My dad was such a godly man I had no idea until after he died when I was 13 that in his younger days he had been a drinker who got into fights in bars, etc. I just could not imagine it.

I fully understand your disillusionment with a lot of what goes on in church. There is plenty to be upset about. However anytime human beings are involved there is going to be a lot of imperfection.

That imperfection includes duplicty, selfishness, ignorance, deceit, lying, stealing, etc. However within one of these imperfect institutions there is almost always people who are good, honest hearted, and doing their best to do what is right.

What I fear about your current situation is that it is something I have seen quite a bit in my 51 years of living and right now am dealing with it in one of my own grown children. It seems that since there are no perfect churches with perfect people in them you just are not going to go to any. I know and respect your intellect so I have to believe that deep down you know this is not right.

We have a responsibility to put ourselves in the best possible church so that we can submit to be taught from the five fold ministry. However no church is perfect and we must realize that going in.

I believe the enemy of our souls uses the faults of the church to cause bitterness and weariness where he can and then those things to cause people to give up on church. Satan does not want you to be spirtually fed. You have to remember that is his goal.

Bottom line is that you find the best church you can with a pastor you believe is upstanding (although still impefect) and plug yourself in. Pray for the imperfect saints and win new honest hearted ones to outnumber the ones who are just playing church and not really living christian lives.

ILG
09-05-2010, 09:24 AM
QUOTE=CC1;959666
I fully understand your disillusionment with a lot of what goes on in church. There is plenty to be upset about. However anytime human beings are involved there is going to be a lot of imperfection.

Hey CC1. Thanks for the feedback. I think you may have missed the irony in my post. The irony is in how people say the church is so much better than "the world" and then when things aren't perfect, people fall back on the "well we're only human". Well.....the church holds itself to a higher standard and then, in my experience, falls far short. So, I am not seeing church attendance to be gaining me anything at this point in my life. That's not to say some people don't gain anything. I am not saying people should quit. I'm just saying I am not seeing the point for myself so much. It is a effort in frustration.

What I fear about your current situation is that it is something I have seen quite a bit in my 51 years of living and right now am dealing with it in one of my own grown children. It seems that since there are no perfect churches with perfect people in them you just are not going to go to any. I know and respect your intellect so I have to believe that deep down you know this is not right.

I appreciate your compliment about my intellect, but I don't "know" that not going to church isn't right. It feels right to me. In fact, it feels great except for I miss the idea of community. (I say "idea" because the experience of community always fell far short.) Will I never return to church? I'm sure I will visit on occasion. I don't know that I will ever be a member anywhere or attend regularly again. What are you afraid of with your grown children not attending? My only fear about my grown children is that their children will grow up with a value void, but perhaps there is a better way to fill that value void. So far, church has not impressed me with filling value voids. God has done a pretty good job, but the men behind the curtains just keep pulling switches and making things roar with electrical equipment. And when you say something to them they get all offended like you should know better. They too often say and do not do.

Anyway CC1, thanks. I feel content for the first time in many years. I am failing to see how that is a bad thing.

Sweet Pea
09-05-2010, 09:59 AM
ILG - I feel bad for the pain you experienced while in the ministry. I wish there was a way to "make it better" - but realize that there is nothing any of us can do.

I do have one question: In your refusal to go to church, or rather to become a part of a "community" or "body" of believers, what do you do with the scripture that says "forsake not the assembling of yourselves together" ?

Just curious. May God bless you!

ILG
09-05-2010, 11:06 AM
ILG - I feel bad for the pain you experienced while in the ministry. I wish there was a way to "make it better" - but realize that there is nothing any of us can do.

I do have one question: In your refusal to go to church, or rather to become a part of a "community" or "body" of believers, what do you do with the scripture that says "forsake not the assembling of yourselves together" ?

Just curious. May God bless you!

Well there's a few things that could be done to explain it differently than is popularly explained. One explanation is in how a person defines forsaking an assembling together. Another is that the male Jews were required to go to the temple once a year and that's all. For me, it's basically irrelevant. I don't view this in the context it was once taught and I don't take the Bible so literally. Of course, if a person believes that it means you have to go to church three times a week or you are betraying God, then, by all means, a person wouldn't want to skip church or not be a member somewhere.

Sarah
09-05-2010, 11:50 AM
Algae,

I am getting ready for church so have only had time to read your posts and just a few of other peoples responses.

First of all your family's history has made me once again so thankful for being raised in a good Christian home. My dad was such a godly man I had no idea until after he died when I was 13 that in his younger days he had been a drinker who got into fights in bars, etc. I just could not imagine it.

I fully understand your disillusionment with a lot of what goes on in church. There is plenty to be upset about. However anytime human beings are involved there is going to be a lot of imperfection.

That imperfection includes duplicty, selfishness, ignorance, deceit, lying, stealing, etc. However within one of these imperfect institutions there is almost always people who are good, honest hearted, and doing their best to do what is right.

What I fear about your current situation is that it is something I have seen quite a bit in my 51 years of living and right now am dealing with it in one of my own grown children. It seems that since there are no perfect churches with perfect people in them you just are not going to go to any. I know and respect your intellect so I have to believe that deep down you know this is not right.

We have a responsibility to put ourselves in the best possible church so that we can submit to be taught from the five fold ministry. However no church is perfect and we must realize that going in.

I believe the enemy of our souls uses the faults of the church to cause bitterness and weariness where he can and then those things to cause people to give up on church. Satan does not want you to be spirtually fed. You have to remember that is his goal.

Bottom line is that you find the best church you can with a pastor you believe is upstanding (although still impefect) and plug yourself in. Pray for the imperfect saints and win new honest hearted ones to outnumber the ones who are just playing church and not really living christian lives.


I appreciate this post so much, CC1. You just have a way with words! I hope ILG will take them to heart. Not only do we have ourselves to think of, but we have a HUGE responsibility to our children and grandchildren. Without God and the church, where would we be?

coadie
09-05-2010, 03:17 PM
I remember being in the world before the UPC. I felt the injustice of many things and saw the structure of the world and how it favored some over others and gave perks to some over others that didn't deserve it, that perhaps slimed their way up, or, often were simply born into their silver spoon status.

I was raised poor, with an alcoholic father who had been the illegitimate son of a 16 year old raped girl. My Dad was later adopted by a divorced man who married my grandmother. They had four more children. They worked a farm and all slept in the upstairs of a house that grew huge icicles on the inside in the winter and dripped on them in the spring. They divorced after my Dad moved out because my grandfather was having an affair and threw my aunt on the floor when she confronted him about it.

My mother grew up materially poor in a family of 14 children. They ate molasses sandwiches and slept many to a bed, covered with coats and blankets for warmth. My mother gave her cousin an empty spool of thread for her birthday. My grandfather was a commerical seasonal fisherman. My grandmother used to cry in the outhouse because she had so many children and did not want anymore, but the Catholic church did not believe in birth control and my grandfather always said "God will provide".

Compared to my parents, I grew up well off, in a house with wood heat that didn't drip on me. We had a real toilet that flushed. I got two new outfits for school every year and if we were lucky, on our back to school trip, we were allowed a cheesburger at McDonalds. (No happy meals as they were too expensive.) We ate venison and fish and garden produce.

My mother used to sing in bars when I was young and us kids often went. I talked to many a drunk on a barstool. My brother and I would stick our arms up into the pool table and pull the balls out because we didn't have any quarters to play pool. My Mom and Dad would fight as my Mom would want to go home after a while and my Dad would want to stay. My Dad used to give me peppermint schnapps on the rocks when I was young. I got drunk first at age 12 and continued the pattern until I was 19.

I saw much injustice in the world. I saw how people who were born into perfect (to me) families had it knocked. I saw how they knew the rules and they knew how to use them to their advantage. I saw how they got all the perks at school and how they were popular and how they got good grades, nice clothes, cars, money and perks.

I did some of that stuff. But I had to work very hard for whatever I got, because it was never handed on a silver platter. I had to learn the rules for myself and earn my keep.

That is a lot of information about a home. My mother won her younger sisters to Jesus. They and my mom won the youngest boys. The youngest boys won the older sons. The older sons started Sunday afternoon prayer meetings and eventually won grandad and about 40 others in a small community to Christ. I don't think teenage boys are known for small group prayer meetings. Grandad was a violent drunk. I never heard a word about it from my mom. she took the brunt of it I found out but she forgave him.
Grandad became a big soul winner after age 54 repentence. I learn about this stuff at funerals because my mother only repeated some of the worst stuff in prayer to the Heavenly Father.
Bad to the bone grandad has nearly 40 sons, daughters sons in law grand children and descendents in full time ministry, missionary work or teaching at bible colleges.. There are over 200 offspring. Grandad would after conversion visit bars, beer joints and saloons and witness.

There is healing in the blood.

*AQuietPlace*
09-05-2010, 04:22 PM
I don't really view church as a place where I go to "get something", although I do get something. But I see it more as community, coming together to encourage each other, share our faith, pray with each other, meet each others needs. I certainly don't expect perfection. We're here to learn how to be disciples of Christ, and to be His hands in the world. If I pulled away from church, I'd feel that I had pulled myself away from serving others. To me that's one of the main purposes of church. To come together as a family, to share each others sorrows and joys.

Pro31:28
09-05-2010, 04:55 PM
I don't really view church as a place where I go to "get something", although I do get something. But I see it more as community, coming together to encourage each other, share our faith, pray with each other, meet each others needs. I certainly don't expect perfection. We're here to learn how to be disciples of Christ, and to be His hands in the world. If I pulled away from church, I'd feel that I had pulled myself away from serving others. To me that's one of the main purposes of church. To come together as a family, to share each others sorrows and joys.

I would agree with you , AQP, but in the other hand, some of the most precious times I have had with the Lord has been when I was without a church due to a move, or other situation. It certainly didn't feel like that at the time, but in retrospect I realized that I often depended on my pastor to tell me what God said, rather than listening for myself. Fasting when the church is fasting if is one thing, fasting when God calls you to is a completely different experience.
In addition to all this, I am a dyed-in-the-wool approval addict who will do whatever I can to please people. I am every home-missions pastor answer to prayer, at first glance. When I commit I will do anything, including teach Sunday School, help out with youth night, collect donations for the homeless and call everyone who has ever walked through the doors of our church to tell them that next Sunday is, "Wear Your Favorite Hat To Church" Sunday. Church has often been hard work for me, and when I would verbalize that I was tired, well-intentioned people would tell me that "The Lord is your strength", followed by, "Make sure you remember to bring a lasagna to the potluck".

Through time, prayer, an amazing husband, and an intuitive pastor, I am learning to curb my approval addiction, but I understand that sometimes taking a break from church, or at least taking a break from doing all kinds of things "for the Lord" can be a good thing.

Just a thought

CC1
09-05-2010, 10:45 PM
Algae,

How do you reconcile Ephesians 4:11-16 with your take on church attendance and the current role of a pastor, teachers, evangelists, etc in your life.

Also have you considered the state of the churches in the Epistles? Paul had to write them about how to deal with a man sleeping with his mother or stepmother! Doesn't sound much like a perfect Christian church to me. Seems like there has never been one.

For those who may think I am speaking too frankly to Algae we have been forum friends for a long time.

Praxeas
09-06-2010, 12:17 AM
Who is Algae?

Hoovie
09-06-2010, 12:18 AM
Who is Algae?

CC1's fav nick for ILG.

Praxeas
09-06-2010, 12:46 AM
Ah...I see

ILG
09-06-2010, 08:31 AM
Algae,

How do you reconcile Ephesians 4:11-16 with your take on church attendance and the current role of a pastor, teachers, evangelists, etc in your life.

I have a lot of thoughts on this and not sure that I will share them all, but when I was LOOKING for this in my life, I couldn't find it. Just a lot of heartache and bad advice. My first pastor was more a pastor than anyone, but he was never very involved and left me down countless times. He never called after we left nor have any of the others that were supposed to care about this. Later, when we were attending the trinitarian church, my husband approached the pastor about sponsoring him for being a minister for global (you have to have a sponsor) and my husband gave him the paperwork. The pastor said he would get back to my husband on it and never did.....and that wasn't the first time he did that sort of thing. It was just more of the same. My son, I wanted to get him involved in some volunteer work and I set things up with the youth pastor for my son to do some computer work for the church, talked to him about our background (we also did that with the pastor in a formal meeting) and the youth pastor said he would get back with us after he went on a trip. I asked him if he would like an email reminder. He said he would. I sent him three email reminders and he never got back with us (we had communicated by email previously so I know his address worked). My family has been hurt enough. We really liked this church above all the others and the ministry and everything. Everyone who we have tried to respect as leadership has voted themselves out of the position. I am done trying. It has occurred to me that God doesn't necessarily want this for my life. When do you stop beating your head on a brick wall? I got sick last year and that is when we stopped going to church. It wasn't really an intentional thing, but it felt so good that we just kept skipping and skipping until here we are.

I have been reading books by Bart Erhman and it makes me question a lot. If you have read his books at all, you will know what I am questioning. The first book I read by him, I cried and it was as if a fresh breeze blew into my life.

Also have you considered the state of the churches in the Epistles? Paul had to write them about how to deal with a man sleeping with his mother or stepmother! Doesn't sound much like a perfect Christian church to me. Seems like there has never been one.

Probably never has been one. Sounds like a good reason to stay away, maybe.

For those who may think I am speaking too frankly to Algae we have been forum friends for a long time.

Nah.....CC1 is just showing he cares, that's all.

You never did answer my question about your kids. What are you afraid is going to happen to them if they quit going to church?

CC1
09-06-2010, 08:56 AM
Algae, I apologize for not answering your question about my kids and church. Somehow I missed it.

I have been patient with my child who is not attending church. The reason I am concerned is that I believe in the scripture I pointed out to you. I believe pastors, teachers, evangelists, etc are all in our lives for the reasons pointed out in Ephesians.

Why would I not be concerned about someone who shuns some of the key inputs the Bible says are there to develop us as Christians?

Plus it is not like he is having home church or is praying or studying the world like he should. The funny thing is that of all of my kids he is the one I never thought would go through this phase. There was a period of time I felt deep down that he might even enter the ministry.

I believe there is a spirit of rebellion and narcicissm operating in the world today in a great way. Particularly among young people. The spirit of the age is to adapt everything to fit yourself. What makes you comfortable. Truths or processes that are uncomfortable are avoided. I believe that is a dangerous state to be in.

I don't want my kids to have escaped the legalism of my religous upbringing to only go to the other extreme where organized religon is shunned.

missourimary
09-06-2010, 09:06 AM
I appreciate this post so much, CC1. You just have a way with words! I hope ILG will take them to heart. Not only do we have ourselves to think of, but we have a HUGE responsibility to our children and grandchildren. Without God and the church, where would we be?

Without GOD, we would be lost. Without the church? Depends on your definition of church, and the kind of church you know, I suppose.

The church doesn't save us. Only Jesus can do that.

How do you reconcile Ephesians 4:11-16 with your take on church attendance and the current role of a pastor, teachers, evangelists, etc in your life.

Also have you considered the state of the churches in the Epistles? Paul had to write them about how to deal with a man sleeping with his mother or stepmother! Doesn't sound much like a perfect Christian church to me. Seems like there has never been one...


Do we have to go to church to have people in those various roles in our lives?

The difference between what ILG and I and others have experienced and what happened in Corinth is that the leadership in Corinthians didn't put themselves in the place of God. People make mistakes, and even blatantly sin. But Paul took steps to resolve the issue in Corinthians. Too often today people only take steps to hide the issues, including condemning those who would speak out against sin.


ILG, thanks for the post.

missourimary
09-06-2010, 09:11 AM
Very interesting, I don't have much faith in the Machine , I do believe it is broken , and in need of repair..... But still there is hope God is different , He is not a man and can't lie. We have to please him,and Him alone .I am trying to learn that and how to do that. { according to what He teaches me in his word } Not based on religion, or tradition.The hard part is being looked at as sinners by those who say they are Christian [ apostolic ] because we don't fit in.

Jesus didn't fit in either. They called Him a sinner, too. When I read about Bartimaeus being thrown out of the temple for saying he followed Jesus, I realized that Jesus was probably thrown out too, if His followers were. That thought has been a comfort.

ILG
09-06-2010, 09:49 AM
Algae, I apologize for not answering your question about my kids and church. Somehow I missed it.

I have been patient with my child who is not attending church. The reason I am concerned is that I believe in the scripture I pointed out to you. I believe pastors, teachers, evangelists, etc are all in our lives for the reasons pointed out in Ephesians.

Why would I not be concerned about someone who shuns some of the key inputs the Bible says are there to develop us a Christians?

Plus it is not like he is having home church or is praying or studying the world like he should. The funny thing is that of all of my kids he is the one I never thought would go through this phase. There was a period of time I felt deep down that he might even enter the ministry.

I believe there is a spirit of rebellion and narcicissm operating in the world today in a great way. Particularly among young people. The spirit of the age is to adapt everything to fit yourself. What makes you comfortable. Truths or processes that are uncomfortable are avoided. I believe that is a dangerous state to be in.

I don't want my kids to have escaped the legalism of my religous upbringing to only go to the other extreme where organized religon is shunned.

Thanks for sharing, CC1. Fair and honest enough.

ILG
09-06-2010, 10:11 AM
ILG, thanks for the post.

You're welcome, MM. Thanks for the input.

NotforSale
09-06-2010, 12:23 PM
The injustice I felt went deep. I had a young bitterness about the world and how it was run. I resented the people who looked down on the less fortunate as somehow lesser people.

When I was 19, I got into the church. The experience with God was wonderful and marvelous. It was like nothing I ever felt. "Come with us" , the people said "We have a different system, a different way of life where we care about people. God is no respector of persons. He loves all people. We also believe we should not be respectors of persons".

I loved this message. A God who loved all men equally and did not put one above the other. A system that was like God. I was in heaven.

Many, many promises were made to me through preaching and teaching about God and his church and how things were so mush better, so much different here. My family was concerned about me. They felt I was falling for a line. Some of them called me brainwashed. I blew them all off. What did they know? They did not have the experience I had and I knew how they lived. I had a new life and I was whole hog, hook, line and sinker.

I began to see little things that bothered me, but the message was too good. The experience was too good. The promises were too good. We forged ahead my husband and I, convinced our calling was to take this message to the world. We worked very, very hard, starting a church, advertising, passing out tracts, teaching bible studies, paying for it all and getting no respect and very little help.

Meanwhile, we saw pastors sons given pastorates and silver spoons placed in their mouths. We decided they didn't know what we knew and we knew our message was too important to not pass it on. People are worthwhile no matter who they are and God loves them all. We forged ahead while pastors canvassed in our area and took people from us with promises of big choirs and lots of people. We forged ahead while we were warned not to steal any people from anyone. We forged ahead while we were told to contribute to every program so they could know we were cooperating with them. We forged ahead while they missed sending us Home Missions checks and refused to let us sell baked goods in their churches at Home Missions rallies. We forged ahead while I went to ladies retreats alone, believing the message. We forged ahead and paid the bills mostly alone.

We forged ahead while they told us our families were going to hell and while they made excuses for their own. We forged ahead while we believed the messages and they watered it down.

Finally, we believed we needed to move to a larger church because we were burned out. When we moved to the larger church, we found there were no income records and money spent on the previous pastors personal things. When we took this to the church, many did not believe us. Still, we forged ahead, believing the message. The district board shoved it all under the rug. Still we forged ahead, believing the message. But, the veil was being lifted.

In time, after a shocking personal revelation.....I stopped believing the message. It was about standards at first. I could not believe I had been lied to and duped for 16 years. Pants were not men's apparel. The Bible didn't say women couldn't cut their hair, etc.

But the core message to me stayed the same. God loves all people the same. Injustice should be fought against. We continued to fight, believing this message.

But, when I said standards were not biblical and mentioned all the injustices, I was told we are all human and that this is a human problem, not a UPC one. What? After all the promises I was made about us being the church? What? After all the times I was told that God is no respector of persons? What? After believing standards lies for years, I now find out I believed another one? That the church is just as guilty as everyone else regarding these things?

And indeed, I found out that the church is just as guilty. For as much as it postures itself as being God's people and as much as it says it is better than others and has "the truth", that it is a better way to live, that it is the right way, the only way, the only way not to burn in hell, I find out that it isn't true.

Yes, the problems are human problems. The veil has been lifted. The Wizard of Oz is actually behind the curtain just making things look powerful, incredible and amazing, when the God that they claim exclusive rights to, is actually everywhere and a real promoter of justice and truly, no respector of persons. He is the One I have been serving all along.

I don't go to church anymore. Not often anyway. I keep seeing Wizards behind curtains. I don't know if that will ever change. But, the God I believe in, the God that saved me, I believe that He still believes in justice, in love, in not being a respector of persons and that someday, He will make all this right. He is the God I love and the One I follow. I believe He is not a Wizard behind a curtain.

Powerful words. Thanks for the courage to share what many fear to say.

ILG
09-06-2010, 02:04 PM
Powerful words. Thanks for the courage to share what many fear to say.

Thanks, NFS. I appreciate the feedback.

johnny44
09-06-2010, 04:44 PM
Thank you!BRAVO.That's why I am a JESUS only believer.GBU.

ILG
09-07-2010, 07:56 AM
BRAVO.That's why I am a JESUS only believer.GBU.

What does GBU mean?

johnny44
09-07-2010, 08:56 AM
What does GBU mean?I always took it to mean God Bless You. Am I wrong?

ILG
09-07-2010, 09:18 AM
I always took it to mean God Bless You. Am I wrong?

I dunno. It makes sense though!

berkeley
09-07-2010, 11:58 AM
ILG: Thank you for creating this thread.

CC1: Are you referring to the son that attended the Methodist university? I probably got the denomination wrong. My apologies.

CC1
09-07-2010, 05:01 PM
ILG: Thank you for creating this thread.

CC1: Are you referring to the son that attended the Methodist university? I probably got the denomination wrong. My apologies.

My son's first year of college was at Lipscomb University which is a Church of Christ University in Nashville. Many non Church of Christ folks go there though as they have a good Business program with 100% placement. I wish he had kept on going there instead of moving to the ten year program at a Community College!

ILG
09-08-2010, 08:46 AM
ILG: Thank you for creating this thread.

CC1: Are you referring to the son that attended the Methodist university? I probably got the denomination wrong. My apologies.

You're welcome, Berk. :)

Jason B
09-08-2010, 09:09 AM
ILG, while I understand your frustration, I don't believe that God intended any of us to be christians unto ourselves. I think herein is the problem with organized religion manifest, men attempt to take over the church, instead of sheppherding.

It is very difficult to find a church that truly reaches for the lost, while at the same time not teaching an easy believism, yet not enforcing man made rules or addtional requirements to be saved. I drive an hour one way to church each week, because I can't find a church like that in my area.

Those things said, I completely understand disinfrancshisement with the church over the actions of "christians", especially when they are "leaders" of "the [by implication one and only] church". Personally, the people who have treated me the most hateful, are oneness pentecostal ministers when I suggested that we are justifed by faith, not by works (with the implication that salvation is therefore not limited to those who follow the 3 step doctrine). I still believe in oneness, Jesus name baptism, and in tongues (though not as the only initial evidence), I still have standards, though many would say I have none, because they are bible based, not manual based. However, to most (but not all) of them I am their enemy.

I'm not longer upc, and completely understand why you would leave, however, I would just encourage you not to give up on church. If you believe the Bible, and believe Jesus to be who He said He was, then there are churches somewhere who are doing his work, the sad thing is its hard to find them.

DaffyDuck
09-08-2010, 09:17 AM
ILG, while I understand your frustration, I don't believe that God intended any of us to be christians unto ourselves. I think herein is the problem with organized religion manifest, men attempt to take over the church, instead of sheppherding.

It is very difficult to find a church that truly reaches for the lost, while at the same time not teaching an easy believism, yet not enforcing man made rules or addtional requirements to be saved. I drive an hour one way to church each week, because I can't find a church like that in my area.

Those things said, I completely understand disinfrancshisement with the church over the actions of "christians", especially when they are "leaders" of "the church". Personally, the people who have treated me the most hateful, are oneness pentecostal ministers when I suggested that we are justifed by faith, not by works (with the implication that salvation is therefore not limited to those who follow the 3 step doctrine). [B]I still believe in oneness, Jesus name baptism, and in tongues (though not as the only initial evidence), I still have standards, though many would say I have none, because they are bible based, not manual based. However, to most (but not all) of them I am their enemy.

I'm not longer upc, and completely understand why you would leave, however, I would just encourage you not to give up on church. If you believe the Bible, and believe Jesus to be who He said He was, then there are churches somewhere who are doing his work, the sad thing is its hard to find them.


Who said anything about her being a Christian unto herself?

What about people who do not, necessarily, share your theological values?

Jason B
09-08-2010, 09:51 AM
Who said anything about her being a Christian unto herself?

What about people who do not, necessarily, share your theological values?

To not attend a church is to be a christian essentially unto yourself, unless you get involved in ahouse church/study group, something. I don't think "fellowshipping" on the internet with anonymous yahoos constititues fellowship. ;)to all the yahoos. :D

As to the second question. I never said it was necessary to share my theological views, if in fact you read my post more carefully you would see that I don't believe its my way or the highway. However the concept that as christians we should belong to a fellowship is bible basics. Whether that fellowship meets in a church building, or in a house is I believe irrelevant. However to not meet for prayer, worship, singing, preaching/teaching is to drift away from God, because we are not following His Word. Im not saying ILG is away from God, but if I'm reading her post correctly and she isn't having any chrisitan fellowship outside of AFF, if that continues for a long period of time, I believe it will be very difficult for her to remain a christian over the long term.

Aquila
09-08-2010, 12:52 PM
To not attend a church is to be a christian essentially unto yourself, unless you get involved in ahouse church/study group, something. I don't think "fellowshipping" on the internet with anonymous yahoos constititues fellowship. ;)to all the yahoos. :D

As to the second question. I never said it was necessary to share my theological views, if in fact you read my post more carefully you would see that I don't believe its my way or the highway. However the concept that as christians we should belong to a fellowship is bible basics. Whether that fellowship meets in a church building, or in a house is I believe irrelevant. However to not meet for prayer, worship, singing, preaching/teaching is to drift away from God, because we are not following His Word. Im not saying ILG is away from God, but if I'm reading her post correctly and she isn't having any chrisitan fellowship outside of AFF, if that continues for a long period of time, I believe it will be very difficult for her to remain a christian over the long term.

I think it depends on circumstances. If one is in prison, a very sick shut in, or in a distant region where there are no Christians the internet is the best option of fellowship. It's like writing letters.

However, I generally agree. Rather it be a traditional church, house church, or Bible study group... a Christian needs fellowship. Even if it's just simply another Christian.

iceniez
09-09-2010, 07:39 AM
Jesus didn't fit in either. They called Him a sinner, too. When I read about Bartimaeus being thrown out of the temple for saying he followed Jesus, I realized that Jesus was probably thrown out too, if His followers were. That thought has been a comfort.

You are right.