Quote:
Originally Posted by Praxeas
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Iron Bladder
Oneness Pentecostals such as Mr Blume claim that God assumes the three roles (or manifestations) of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit in time from Jesus’ birth. But I would state here that both of these positions are problematic for the Oneness view, because before Jesus’ conception in Mary’s womb, Luke states that; ‘The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee,’ ( Luke 1:35), indicating that God already existed as the Holy Spirit, before Jesus’ birth and even before his conception; (Mr Blume alludes to this in paraphrase in his post). |
Where did Mr Blume claim the HOly Ghost did not already exist? |
I missed IB's quote here.
Right, Praxeas! Now I know what you mean by Iron Bladder twisting what we say and misrepresenting us! I NEVER SAID THE HOLY GHOST MANIFESTATION DID NOT EXIST BEFORE THE INCARNATION. Neither do I believe it. The Holy Ghost is a manifestation that existed long before incarnation!
Seems to me that Iron Bladder never really properly understood oneness. So he cannot say he was once oneness.