GOP’s Rand Paul Calls For 14.5% Flat Tax

[Originalist]

Originally Posted by Jito463

The Constitution does not have any stipulation against an income tax. In fact, one could argue that the call for the "general welfare" (not to be confused with the welfare state) is grounds for exercising an income tax. However, I am all for an alternative system to income tax. I'm not sure this is the best solution, but I'd love to at least see one be seriously considered by congress.

Remember, the American Revolution was *NOT* about taxation, it was about taxation with *NO* representation.

Mind you, I think we're nearing a point where one could argue we're almost there again.

Actually until the ratification of the 16th amendment in 1913, income tax was illegal per the Constitution. The General Welfare clause only applies to the powers specifically enumerated to the Federal Government by the States in the Constitution.

[Jito463]

Originally Posted by Originalist

Actually until the ratification of the 16th amendment in 1913, income tax was illegal per the Constitution. The General Welfare clause only applies to the powers specifically enumerated to the Federal Government by the States in the Constitution.

That's not entirely accurate. Prior to 1913, an income tax would have been considered a direct tax, and would have been required to be enumerated based on the census population data. After 1913, it was classified an indirect tax, and exempted from that qualification. It was not, however, illegal prior to that. Unless I misread something, in which case, feel free to point out the error to me. I won't be offended.

As to the General Welfare clause, I concur wholeheartedly. The greatest problem with our government right now, is that 'We the People' are not holding our representatives accountable, and letting them run ramshod over their Constitutional limitations.