San Diego UPC Choir TEARS IT UP with Michael English and Mark Lowry

Originally Posted by Praxeas

You didn't say "anyone" though you said THE UPC, you made a sweeping generalization.

Yes, it was a generalization but it certainly seems that those individuals in the UPC that don't consider trinitarians unsaved are in the minority. I suspect that if you went to the powers that be out there in the UPC Vatican they would tell you that trinitarians are not saved.

Why can't something be doctrinally sound from someone that is unsaved?

Because bad trees cannot bear good fruit.

Just because someone has some doctrine incorrect does not mean ALL of their doctrine is.

But since their lack of salvation is being based on one particular doctrine (okay, maybe two doctrines)...

Jehovahs Witnesses still believe in the virgin birth. They are doctrinally sound on that, but not on other areas.

Are they really so doctrinally sound on that? What do they believe about what was in Mary's womb? Just because they might get one thing partly right doesn't mean I'm going to start subscribing to Watchtower or start attending the Kingdom Hall.