FOX News: Illegal to Kill Osama

[Praxeas]

Originally Posted by Jermyn Davidson

No Shep made a statement and asked if anyone else was going to jump on it.

it was a journalistic query. He wasn't making an argument. There probably are factual realities about this making it illegal. Shep was asking if anyone was raising that issue. I don't see how you can construe this as the right or fox news arguing it was illegal.

[Praxeas]

Originally Posted by Jermyn Davidson

I never disagreed with this.

I have emphatically stated this a couple times on a coupe of threads.

But not here. Here you argued with him over his point

[Praxeas]

Originally Posted by Jermyn Davidson

It wasn't illegal.

The act was carried out by the military forces of a country that is at war.

The act was carried out in the conduct of war.

In war, people kill people.

Not at war with Pakistan. They are a sovereign nation.

[Praxeas]

Originally Posted by tstew

Prax, read through the thread. Also look at what is being said in some right wing quarters in other places.

Where do I look to find these "right wing quarters"?

My point is, there may be some legalities involved, but I don't care. If it was illegal, I don't care. The greater good was to get the man

And my point is that Shep was not making an argument. He was asking if anyone was questioning this issue and the answer was no...until I posted someone from the UN was asking...is that what you mean by right wing?