No tithe outside of Israel?

[Esaias]

Originally Posted by Tithesmeister

Okay Esaias,

Let’s do it like this. You answer yes or no.

In the day that Nehemiah and Malachi were walking the earth. You are raising cattle. You have ten head to tithe which is one beef.

Your cow that you tithe is worth 50 shekels. Could you give fifty shekels for your tithe or would that be a transgression of the law?

Please answer yes or no.

Would tithing fifty shekels instead of the cow be a transgression of the law?

The post you quoted, as well as numerous others in this thread, answer your question, anticipate where you (think you) are going with it, and address those concerns as well. For some reason, you aren't keeping up with the progress of the discussion, but rather you appear stuck on the idea that "anybody who gives ten percent of their income to the church is just wrong, wrong, wrong!"

You seem not to be actually reading the thread. I suggest you review it carefully, then you may be able to participate with something relevant to the topic.