Well, I know I gonna be veering off topic a bit with this but.. to answer your question:
Quote:
Originally Posted by BoredOutOfMyMind
So persons and manifestations is different to some?
|
Sure. What we call manifestations or offices of one God, they see as 3 different persons within a unified Godhead.
The
"manifestations" vs. "persons" thing is not the only dividing issue here. The other 2 key issue are is the
eternal pre-existence of the Son (as opposed tot he begotten nature of the Son) , and
the personhood of the Holy Ghost.
First, we understand from scripture that the Son was brought forth into being (begotten) at a particular point in time for the purpose of redeeming man. They say the Son always existed, that is to say He and eternally pre-existed before God even made the universe.
Here's the problem: Logically and rationally, one can't be "begotten" (which implies
a particular moment of being brought into being) and "
eternally pre-existent" at the same time. Not a problem for the Trinitarians. They simply came up with the bizarre and inherently contradictory doctrine that the son was "
eternally begotten"!! (convenient, huh?). When asked how one can be eternally begotten, well, they have an answer for that too -- "Its a mystery" !!
Second, we recognize that the Holy Spirit is simply the Spirit of God (aka "God our Father", etc) . Many scriptures bear that out, of course. God is holy. God is spirit. God's very nature is "holy spirit". Pretty basic stuff. But since they're predisposed to think of God in
triadic terms, Trinitarians have a huge blind spot there.
The selfsame entity is referred to in scripture as "The Spirit", "The Holy Spirit", "The Spirit of God", "The Spirit of the Lord", "The Spirit of the Father", etc . Its all one and the same, of course, but Trinitarianism takes the "
Spirit of the Father" to be different from "
The Holy Spirit" , and makes them into separate divine persons of their "Trinity" , in order to fit into their 3 person formula.
Hence, in their theology this is what we end up with...
with the "'Spirit" (3rd person)...now being a divine "person" distinct from "the Father" (1st Person)...and the begotten Son now being the "
eternally pre-existent "God the Son" (2nd person)...
VOILA!! We have a Trinity!! ...comprised of the 1st , 2nd, and 3rd [eternally distinct] persons of the Godhead.
...this of course, is something neither Paul nor any other New Testament writer ever taught.
.