Quote:
Originally Posted by Joseph Miller
Do you think you can reflect Jesus and NOT have outward holiness? If you reflect (look like the world around you) then you are not reflecting Jesus.
|
This is the inherent problem with such statements when they are used as rhetoric.
Joseph poses, what he supposes, is a rhetorical question then draws a conclusion based on what he supposes the answer will be.
The problem is that the question creates a false dilemma as well as his conclusion.
The issue is not whether I believe in outward holiness, I do (one should wear clothes, for example), but rather what does he mean by outward holiness. Also, what he means by "looking like the world around you" needs clarification.
He should ask the question in the following manner: "Do you think you can reflect Jesus and NOT have outward holiness, as defined by me? If you reflect (look like the world around you, as I define looking like the world around you) then you are not reflecting Jesus."
If Joseph had stated the questions that way then a discussion would follow that would be interesting. But by stating them that way would make he looks judgmental, even though in my experience that is what OP's are being when this discussion comes up.
But since he didn't state it that way....
judging by his picture I would say that he looks like the world around him...by that am I to judge that he is NOT reflecting Jesus??
a
Threaded Mode
