American Idol Season 10 ~ 2011

[Socialite]

Originally Posted by notofworks

I know one of your favorites is Stefano, but for some reason, he's had a hard time getting votes. He was nearly voted off after doing "Hello", which was a masterpiece. He wasn't voted into the top 10, has been in the bottom 3 twice after singing masterpieces, so I'm afraid that he won't survive after doing that last night. It's a bummer. He's one of the best ever on AI.

It's strange. He's a GREAT singer.

Best ever? Eek... sounding like Steven Tyler

[Socialite]

Originally Posted by rgcraig

I agree - - you'd think he would get some teen girls following him because he's a cutie, but his personality doesn't show at all so maybe that's keeping the votes low. I hate that it ends up being a popularity vote really.

Pia is awesome, but she's a performer - not an entertainer and I think that's going to hurt her. She seems like a fish out of water last night trying to be all cool and hip. Her voice is flawless though.

Ummmm.... I didn't pick up the "fish out of water" but she definitely could use some coaching for stage performance.

The group performances this year have been LOUSY lol These singers don't blend as well as others in past seasons.

[Socialite]

Originally Posted by notofworks

Oh man, it was hard to watch her last night. I don't mind, at all, having her just stand there and sing. Plus, that outfit!!!! Can they PLEASE never have Gwen Stefani on there again to dress people?

Speaking of "just stand there and sing", why the heck is it SO important for people to "Perform"? The Beatles never "performed", they just wrote great songs, played average music, and stood there doing what they did. They didn't have to have 95 dancers, fire-breathing dragons, hovering smoke, and media productions.

To me, when a person has to "Perform", they're saying, "I'm not good enough on my own." I've been disappointed when they continually tell Stefano that he needs to perform. He's a GREAT singer. I wish that were enough.

And last night when Jennifer Lopez was telling Pia to work on her moves and dancing, and blah, blah, I wanted to throw something at the TV. I was thinking, "Yeah, Jennifer, you have to do that stuff because you can't sing!! Pia, unlike you, CAN sing!!"

Put Billy Joel at a piano and have him sing, "She's Got A Way About Her". Let The Beatles simply sing, "Hey Jude". I'll take that over the light and fire shows any day.

Good points, NOW. In the industry today, to perform at concerts, unless you have it like one of the greatest to ever walk in shoe leather, stage performance is part of the game. If you want to do it because you're just dang good, maybe AI isn't the avenue to roll?

Like for Pia, even if she doesn't shake it like J. Lo, emotionally connecting with the audience is something the Beatles did do.

[Socialite]

Originally Posted by rgcraig

Yep! I completely agree with you!!!

I do too. But AI is more a pop culture show. You aren't going to get artists like that. That's why it's rare to have artists like Paul on. And show me a modern-day rocker that doesn't work a stage, and work the audience.

Our demand for music today goes beyond playing a record, we are a music video, concert-going, visual audience. Gone are the days of music just being something people listened to (actually, ironically, music was originally visual -- think Classical music sans recording devices ).

[Socialite]

Originally Posted by rgcraig

OMW

JUST NOW SAW IT...



SHOCKED....


That's absolutely ridiculous. Time to limit 1 vote per person or something.

[Socialite]

I say look for Stefano, Lauren... Scotty? Jacob? Look for some surprises tonight!

I guessed it completely wrong. I mean, I got Stefano. Guessed there might be a surprise... like MAYBE Lauren, MAYBE Jacon, but had no clue it'd be Pia. Stunned.

[The Mrs]

Yes!

Yes!

Yes!!!


I was sooooo hoping it would be Pia!!!

The deep, dark recesses of my mind were telling me it should be her, but I ignored it, thinking she was an American favorite.

Boy, was I wrong, and should have listened to my gut instinct with my predictions.

She shouldn't have kept promising America that she would 'do better next week'. She never came through with those promises. I think it boiled down to her self-control and being too self-conscious. Does that make sense? She should have taken acting lessons or something where they would make her do something way over the top to break that carefully controlled veneer.

She didn't leave because of her voice.

[CC1]

Unlike The Mrs. I thought Pia was one of the stronger contestants. I expected her to at least be in the top four. Very shocking results tonight.

[notofworks]

Originally Posted by Socialite

It's strange. He's a GREAT singer.

Best ever? Eek... sounding like Steven Tyler

Socialite, you're getting like Hoovie. I didn't say he was the best ever, I said ONE OF the best.

[notofworks]

Originally Posted by The Mrs

Yes!

Yes!

Yes!!!


I was sooooo hoping it would be Pia!!!

The deep, dark recesses of my mind were telling me it should be her, but I ignored it, thinking she was an American favorite.

Boy, was I wrong, and should have listened to my gut instinct with my predictions.

She shouldn't have kept promising America that she would 'do better next week'. She never came through with those promises. I think it boiled down to her self-control and being too self-conscious. Does that make sense? She should have taken acting lessons or something where they would make her do something way over the top to break that carefully controlled veneer.

She didn't leave because of her voice.

You are tone-deaf. You have to be. I had suggested hearing aids for you a couple of weeks ago, but strike that...they wouldn't do any good. You can't carry a tune, can you?

In my opinion, and of course it's the correct opinion, Pia was the best female contestant in the ten years of AI.