Trinity Diagnosis

[Timmy]

Originally Posted by Pliny

That is correct. DID is the new way of talking about MPD. Nowhere does Oneness speak of multiple personalities.

The ONE person of God manifesting Himself in multiple ways is NOT MPD - DID.

If it is your intent to show that Oneness has MPD/DID then present the evidence. I have presented the evidence for the Trinitarian doctrine of three persons in One God and given the diagnosis. It is up to you to prove the diagnosis wrong and/or prove the same diagnosis for the Oneness position which you cannot because there are not distinct persons within the Oneness paradigm.

I'm not trying to prove anything. What I am saying is your post could have been written, with a few changes, by a Trinny as a critique of Oneness, and it would make more sense. Oneness has a single person who speaks at different times in different voices (as you said), and sometimes appears as an animal (as you said). Further, this hypothetical Trinny might point out that this one person talks to himself, knows different things as different manifestations, has different desires (wills), etc. etc. As three persons doing all these things, THERE IS NO MENTAL ILLNESS!

[Pliny]

Originally Posted by Timmy

I'm not trying to prove anything. What I am saying is your post could have been written, with a few changes, by a Trinny as a critique of Oneness, and it would make more sense. Oneness has a single person who speaks at different times in different voices (as you said), and sometimes appears as an animal (as you said). Further, this hypothetical Trinny might point out that this one person talks to himself, knows different things as different manifestations, has different desires (wills), etc. etc. As three persons doing all these things, THERE IS NO MENTAL ILLNESS!

The fallacy of the argument is the same. Oneness doctrine has one person - one God period. For there to be a diagnosis of MPD/DID there fundamentally must be two or more PERSONS/identities of the one being.

Please illustrate where Oneness makes the case for two or more identities of the one being ie God. Without that the fundamental foundation is gone and the house of cards comes tumbling down, Therefore, the Trintiarian cannot accuse Oneness of MPD/DID.

BTW I have made airplane sounds to help children eat. I have acted as a horse while kids were riding me yet I am not diagnosed with MPD/DID because I am ONE PERSON. In Oneness there is ONE GOD period not three.